When Netflix premiered Ransom Canyon in 2025, the expectations were mixed. With Josh Duhamel and Minka Kelly headlining, the series had immediate star power, catching the eye of fans and critics alike. Yet, despite quickly reaching Netflix’s U.S. Top 10 and racking up an impressive 7 million global views in its first week, the critics had plenty to say—both good and bad. Here’s a deeper dive into what the reviews collectively reveal about this western romantic drama.
Chemistry, Cinematics, and Comfort: What’s Good?
To start on a positive note, fans of Ransom Canyon appreciate the on-screen chemistry. Josh Duhamel and Minka Kelly deliver engaging performances, igniting a natural spark that feels authentic. Collider, particularly enthusiastic with a score of 90/100, called it “beautiful and blissfully escapist,” emphasizing how easy it is to lose oneself in the unfolding romance and melodrama.
Visually, the series has been praised widely. The landscapes and cinematography deliver spectacular high-plains vistas that lend authenticity and warmth. Even Jodi Thomas, the author whose novels inspired the series, lauded the rich, Texas-style atmosphere the show captured. Such imagery significantly enhances the experience, pulling viewers effortlessly into its picturesque setting.
Finally, critics who enjoy comfort TV appreciated the show’s easy, binge-worthy qualities. Los Angeles Times described it warmly as a “nicely acted, soapy, soap-bubble show.” The easy-to-follow plot and smooth pacing appeal strongly to viewers seeking relaxation rather than complex narratives or challenging content.
Key Positives:
- Genuine chemistry between Josh Duhamel and Minka Kelly.
- Stunning cinematography capturing authentic high-plains beauty.
- Enjoyable comfort-watch appeal, ideal for bingeing.
Clichés, Sluggish Pace, and Questionable Writing: What’s Not?
However, not everything sparkles in Ransom Canyon. Many critics argue the show heavily borrows from established western hits, earning comparisons—often unfavorable—to Paramount’s hugely popular Yellowstone. NPR criticized it bluntly, calling the series a “less-compelling clone,” lacking the originality necessary to stand out.
Additionally, complaints frequently target the show’s pace and storytelling depth. The Hollywood Reporter found it “featureless and formulaic,” accusing the series of being filled with dialogue that feels like filler. This slow, repetitive narrative might disappoint viewers hoping for more dynamic developments or richer character arcs.
The writing itself has drawn scrutiny too. Outlets like The A.V. Club pointed out dated and stagnant gender politics. Meanwhile, USA Today criticized the dialogue as forced and unnatural, diminishing authenticity and immersion.
Key Negatives:
- Derivative, predictable plot resembling other successful western dramas.
- Sluggish pacing, with numerous filler scenes slowing the story down.
- Uneven writing and problematic gender portrayals affecting the viewing experience.
Verdict — Ransom Canyon (2025) Boring?
So, is Ransom Canyon boring? Ultimately, it depends largely on personal taste. Fans of melodramatic western romance will find enough charm to stay hooked. Yet, if you’re hunting for a groundbreaking narrative or sharp, insightful drama, you might find yourself yawning through its more predictable moments.
Critically speaking, the series earns a modest 5.4 out of 10 on the “boring or not” scale. It isn’t entirely dull, but it lacks freshness and depth. Viewers should adjust expectations accordingly: anticipate easygoing escapism rather than groundbreaking storytelling.
Final Score: 5.4
